Serge Hochar, 1939–2014

Sweetness Without Sugar

A lunch and two recordings with the man behind Chateau Musar. New York, March 27, 2012.

By Jeff Harding

Serge Hochar laughing on a New York sidewalk, cigar in hand, in a pinstripe suit and red tie
After lunch, on the sidewalk, cigar in hand.

In March 2012 I sat down to lunch with Serge Hochar and put a recorder on the table. The first thing he told me was that recorders paralyze his imagination. Then he talked for half an hour like a man whose imagination had never been paralyzed by anything in his life.

Serge took over the winemaking at his father's estate in Lebanon in 1959, kept Chateau Musar going through the civil war, and spent the rest of his life carrying it around the world. He died on New Year's Eve 2014, swimming off Acapulco, just after his 75th birthday.

Years later I found those recordings on an old iPod. Here is some of what he said that day.

On the recorder

“Once somebody is recording or taking pictures, it paralyzes my imagination. I have such a great world of imagination. So once I have a recorder, I say, I should be serious.”

On vintage

“It is wrong to imagine that you could produce wines which are similar each year. On the contrary, I enhance the differences. I am happy that I was never able to repeat.”

On memory

“The grape will die. The wine will live forever.”

On blending

“In the art of winemaking, blending became for me the biggest challenge.”

It took him eighteen years, from 1959 to 1977, to settle on the formula: Cabernet Sauvignon, Cinsault, and Carignan, roughly a third each. Then he described the three grapes as one body:

“One is the backbone. One is the flesh, the muscles. And the Cinsault is the skin.” The velvety skin? I asked. “Yes.”
Serge Hochar at the lunch table behind bottles of 1990 and 1964 Chateau Musar white
On the table: Chateau Musar white, 1990 and 1964.

On taste beyond taste

“In the wine there is a miracle of life. Millions of things combine together, and this creates something you do not expect. This is why I talk about taste beyond taste. It is a dialogue between the wine and the man.”

On pleasing people

“I never do things for somebody else. I make things for me. And if I am happy and satisfied, then I am sure I will find people who will be happy and satisfied. Taste is something so personal.”

On Lebanon

“Lebanon is a melting pot of civilizations. We have been invaded from the East and the West through all of our history. So it is a country of refuge. And this is why it is fascinating.”

A note I left myself after lunch

Sucrosite sans sucre.

Sweetness without sugar. That was how he explained what time does to tannins: with age they stop gripping and turn sweet and rich, with no sugar involved. I grabbed my phone on the way out so I wouldn't lose it. Anyone who has had an old Musar knows exactly what he meant.